Review: The Life of a Showgirl Examines the Price of Fame... and the Joy of Sex
She sold out the world’s biggest tour—celebrating the Eras of her singular career—and didn’t turn in box scores.
She re-recorded many of her previous albums—to vanquish her catalogue being sold—and the fans responded with ferocious momentum.
She got her masters back.
And she got the guy.
For Taylor Swift, The Life of a Showgirl would seem to be a master class in world domination, massive bangers and whispered triumphs. Recorded as her Eras tour crossed Europe, Showgirl is a very in-the-moment rendering of the lightning-rod blonde who came to prominence as a wide-eyed country songwriter and evolved into a full-force pop supernova.
What’s fascinating about Swift’s twelfth album of new music, beyond its mere 12 tracks, is its musicality. Focused on “feel good” classic pop, she eschewed bombastic, larger-than-life arrangements and anthemic proclamations for an engaging chat with her audience.
Which doesn’t mean there aren’t big truths, scores settled or ghosts being unloaded before her "married” era begins. Showgirl trades in brand names and archetypes—Gucci, Elizabeth Taylor, Plaza Athénée, Ophelia—but it serves those who follow her the wisdom she’s learned the hard way about being famous, internet anonymity’s brutality, priorities and betrayal.
Perhaps that’s why Sabrina Carpenter is the lone guest on this Max Martin/Shellback song cycle. On the title track, a young Taylor encounters a glorious showgirl who takes Tay’s bouquet and advises this life isn’t for her; Carpenter takes the second verse outlining classic upper-middle class family dynamic which propel girls into showbiz. Eyes wide open, Taylor hits the bridge and final chorus, claiming her destiny with a nod to her forebear:
I took her pearls of wisdom
Hung them from my neck
I paid my dues with every bruise
I knew what to expect
Beyond determination, she refused to be vanquished. Like some kind of CHR Joan of Arc, she kept riding—"You wanna take a skate on the ice inside my veins/ They ripped me off like false lashes and then threw me away"—unconcerned about others’ motivations. By the time she’s hitting the final chorus, where she owns the life she’s chosen, admitting, “now I know the life of a showgirl, babe/And I’ll never know another… Pain hidden by the lipstick and lace/Sequins are forever…,” there’s a glory to her pursuit.
For all the brio, Showgirl redefines what matters, according her Midwestern roots. With a Casio percolating riff and stacked whispered vocals on “Wi$h Li$t,” she contrasts the acquisitionists' lust for Oscars, Balenciaga shades, yacht life and “a contract with the Real Madrid” with her own desire to settle down in a world where she’s just one more woman “with a driveway with a basketball hoop.” Not judging, merely juxtaposing the rare air with something simpler.
If this seems a betrayal of her hard feminist lean, plenty here impales the double standards women are subjected to/participate in. She embraces and rehabs controversial folks on the foreboding “CANCELLED!”—"did you make a joke only a man could/were you just too smug for your own good"—with an acceptance of how vicious society is to women. Dissolving the condescension and dismissiveness of the term “Honey” when said with literal intent, she takes the language back. “Father Figure” refutes patriarchal disempowerment—“I can make deals with the devil/because my dick is bigger”—by turning the tables, while the gentle, piano-anchored “Eldest Daughter” goes hard on trolls’ battering ubiquity and learning to play small so younger women recognize abuse for what it is—and find better ground.
Honest about the cost of the life she aspired to, the loneliness of being trapped inside fame permeates the string-bathed “Elizabeth Taylor.” That soft, angst whisper that’s meant to be seductive merges with Swift’s signature punch/clap chorus. More than vanquishing bad blood, she’s tempers perception with a desire that might be happily ever after.
This isn’t a prim Older Sister Guide to Life; TayTay gets downright dirty. The effervescent Jackson 5 rhythms of “Wood” celebrates good dick. The double entendres of redwood, hard rock and magic wand pale next to the straight-up “opened my thighs.” Ditto the obsessive hater of “Actually Romantic,” whose chronic attention is viewed for what it is, to the point where “it’s kind of making me wet.”
The hidden gem may be the speculated about “Ruin the Friendship.” Not slaying Blake Lively, but a dreamy mid-tempo that looks back to the friend boy, the denied feelings she had and the reality of being young and fearful. When Abigail, her childhood best friend, calls to say the man is dead, all those tentative moments of chances not taken resolve into Swift’s recommendation to seize the moment, take the risk and not spend a lifetime wondering.
For grown men, Showgirl may be too sweet, too slumber-party intimate. But for generations of women, people who are fluid, outliers looking for reassurance instead of feeling battered, the innocent pop influences and lessons served will make this a repeated listen for its dopamine-inducing melodies, perky time signatures, lyrical refuge in a harsh world—and a happy ending for the girl who’s exploding romantic life has been splattered everywhere for two decades.