Near Truths
by i.b. bad, los angelesVERSIONS OF VALUATION
Taylor Swift

Scooter Braun
Scott Borchetta
THE SPINNERS’ VERSION: Scooter Braun’s name is naturally surfacing in stories about Taylor Swift's having bought back her master recordings, which Scooter sold to Shamrock at a profit after buying them as part of his Big Machine acquisition.
Much speculation has surrounded the size of the check Tay agreed to write, which finally gives her complete control over all of her recorded output. (Scooter is cited in some press coverage as having “encouraged” the deal, and it’s well documented that he offered to sell to her previously and she declined.)
The New York Post had the price as high as $1 billion, which seems excessive. Some insiders have suggested the megastar paid somewhere between $300m and 400m. Most top catalog buyers don’t value this set of copyrights at much more than $300m. Shamrock has declined to comment for fear of tanking the deal—not to mention fear of rousing the Swifty army. Tay is widely understood to be controlling the narrative here, and the entertainment press is happy to oblige. But is she downplaying the cost of a catalog she could’ve had for less if she’d done a deal earlier rather than going to war? We may never know.
The six original albums have done 670k in U.S. activity YTD and earned in the neighborhood of 800m streams, grossing about $4m domestically. The biggest title of the batch is Reputation—yet to be unveiled in a “Taylor’s Version”—at 260k, followed by 1989 at 150k. In 2024, the six original albums sold 2.3m units and amassed 2.8b streams, grossing $13m. Reputation racked up 1m units and 1989 did 500k. The 2023 Eras Tour really juiced U.S. activity on the catalog, which that year sold 3.8m albums and notched 4.8b streams, grossing roughly $25m.
But the big drama surrounding the sale of Big Machine to Scooter and his subsequent sale to Shamrock—and Taylor’s casting herself as the victim and crusader for artists’ rights—definitely served her purposes. The firestorm of publicity surrounding her decision to re-record her albums (doubling the size of her catalog) helped rally her fan base and aided her in becoming the world’s biggest pop star. No other artist has so expertly leveraged a gigantic cult of celebrity and fandom. She has parlayed her massive following into countless award nominations and an ability to move the ratings needle. Her tenacious, obsessive focus and uncommonly shrewd instincts have resulted in a tour that’s grossed nearly $2b. She deserves a standing ovation for her business acumen.
Olivia Rodrigo
Rod Stewart
Sleep Token
EURO WORSHIP: The European summer festival season is about to kick off, with Hyde Park BST (Olivia Rodrigo, Zach Bryan, Sabrina Carpenter, Noah Kahan, ELO; 65k cap per show) and Glastonbury (Neil Young, Rod Stewart with a reunited Faces, O-Rod, The 1975; 220k for fest) leading the charge in Blighty. Being in the U.K. for Hyde Park, Glasto and Wimbledon is absolutely electric for bizniks. Also about to rev up the turnstiles: Primavera Sound Barcelona (Charli xcx, Sabrina, Chappell Roan; 75k per day) and Porto (Charli, Central Cee, Deftones; 45k), Rock am Ring and Rock im Park (Bring Me the Horizon, Korn, Slipknot; 150k combined), Download Festival (Green Day, Sleep Token, Korn; 120k for fest) and Pinkpop (Justin Timberlake, O-Rod, Muse; 70k per day), among many, many others. Will the dicey visa situation, amid Trump’s xenophobic, erratic policy edicts and tweeted tantrums, affect the lineups of these festivals? Insiders believe it won’t.
Sabrina Carpenter
Zach Bryan
NEIL YOUNG
ATROPHY FEST: Chortles continue to ripple through the biz in the wake of the incredibly cheesy American Music Awards, with “cringe” the most frequent descriptor. The most puzzling question: Why do hot artists’ teams let them participate in a spectacle that makes them look like goofballs? It’s damaging to their hard-won credibility, which could be costly down the line when other—and much more consequential—awards shows are being planned and their awards voted on. Rumor has it CBS was allowing artist reps to think their charges wouldn’t be able to get on the VMAs if they didn’t do the AMAs, though such an alleged requirement is most likely a crock of shit. Not a good look for the network that hosts the Grammys.