Black Music Month

20 ESSENTIAL VOCAL PERFORMANCES

May 21, 2025

Out of the thousands (tens of thousands?) to choose from, here are a handful of our all-time favorites, presented chronologically.

Irma Thomas, “It’s Raining” (Minit, 1962)
When Thomas released her first record in 1959, at the age of 18, she already sounded fully grown. Maybe her preternatural poise came from having four kids and two divorces while still in her teens. Whatever the reason, her plainspoken alto has always been guided by a calm whirlwind of confidence which eschews fireworks for understatement, a discerning use of melisma and the expert syncopation associated with her New Orleans hometown. Thomas recorded mainly for independent labels—the melancholy “It’s Raining,” written and produced by the mighty Allen Toussaint, was on Minit—and never got the kind of major-label push that might’ve made her more famous. Although she’s not a household name, she’s revered in the right households. — Rob Tannenbaum

Sam Cooke, "A Change Is Gonna Come" (RCA Victor, 1965)
"A Change Is Gonna Come" appeared as a posthumous single weeks after Cooke's murder in December 1964, timing that made the song feel like an elegy even if it was written as a reflection of the rise of the Civil Rights Movement. A series of interlocked vignettes, "A Change Is Gonna Come" isn't a protest song so much as an inspirational anthem; the focus is not on the struggle but rather deliverance. Drawing from his roots in gospel music, Cooke delivers a stunning performance, sounding simultaneously sorrowful and hopeful; his soaring vocals leave a sense of optimism, not grief, which is why it became an enduring standard, a secular hymn that feels intensely spiritual. — Stephen Thomas Erlewine

Smokey Robinson & the Miracles, “Ooo Baby Baby” (Tamla/Motown, 1965)
Arriving in a swirl of strings, "Ooo Baby Baby" initially scans like the first flush of romance, an impression sustained by Robinson, whose croon immediately seems soft and comforting. This love is a mirage. The first line of the song is "I did you wrong, my heart went out to play," revealing that "Ooo Baby Baby" is an apology as a seduction: the narrator did his lover wrong, so he's pleading for forgiveness. The brilliance of Smokey's performance is that his falsetto is so supple and smooth, it camouflages his transgressions. — STE

Bill Withers, "Ain't No Sunshine" (Sussex, 1971)
Withers defied easy categorization. His songs blended folk and soul in a way that suited the sensitive introspection of the early 1970s; this, his breakthrough hit, epitomized his idiosyncrasies. Stephen Stills strummed folk chords on an acoustic guitar, leaving space for a supple groove that allowed Withers to sing with a disarming frankness. Withers' conversational delivery first seems forlorn, but the song transforms by its midpoint. During a crucial stretch, Withers builds tension by singing "I know" as a mantra, the repetition becoming warm and seductive. — STE

IRMA THOMAS
SAM COOKE
BILL WITHERS

(Gilles Petard/Redferns; RB/Redferns; Gems/Redferns)

Harold Melvin & the Blue Notes, “If You Don’t Know Me by Now” (Philadelphia International, 1972)
It seems implausible now, but there was a time when Teddy Pendergrass was known as just a supporting player in the singing group Harold Melvin & the Blue Notes. At least that’s the way leader Melvin envisioned it. Fortunately, celebrated Philadelphia production tandem Gamble and Huff, who had already helped propel the O’Jays to international fame, saw superstar potential in the powerful Pendergrass. On “If You Don’t Know Me by Now,” the group’s breakthrough pop hit, Teddy turns the pain of an incoming breakup into pure soulman catharsis. — Keith Murphy

Gladys Knight & the Pips, “Midnight Train to Georgia” (Buddah, 1973)
Departing Motown after a long run, Gladys Knight & the Pips situated themselves at Buddah Records, an imprint known in the early '70s for bubblegum and AM pop. On "Midnight Train to Georgia," the group molds those Top 40 styles to suit its style, transforming the country crawl of the Cissy Houston original into snappy pop-soul. Knight wanted to give the ballad a groove reminiscent of Al Green, a shift in tempo that heightens the drama of the story of a woman who decided to follow her lover on his midnight trek out of Hollywood. Knight's fleet, fluid phrasing sustains the narrative tension, leaving the Pips to punctuate her plight with interjections that sweeten her sacrifice. — STE

GLADYS KNIGHT & THE PIPS

(GAB Archive/Redferns)

Marvin Gaye “Distant Lover” (Tamla/Motown, 1974)
Originally buried on the second side of Let's Get It On, "Distant Lover" became a signature Gaye track thanks to its live incarnation, released just a year after its parent LP. Performing in front of an Oakland crowd eager to thrill to his every gesture, Gaye milks all the carnality out of his slow groove, teasing out unexpected high notes during the verses, then climbing to ecstatic heights during an epic conclusion when he's begging his absent lover to come back home. — STE

Earth, Wind & Fire, “Reasons” (Columbia, 1975)
“It’s funny 'cause people say, ‘We played that song at my wedding,’ and I’m like, ‘Did you listen to the lyrics?’,” singer Phillip Bailey once mused to Entertainment Weekly, discussing the ironic one-night-stand subject matter in EW&F’s timeless high-pitched single, “Reasons.” Maybe the confusion lies in the delicate phrasing on the original studio recording. Luckily, the Baltimore Civic Center live version (which remains a Quiet Storm classic despite never being released as a single) unleashes Bailey’s unvarnished, explosive passion, culminating in a riveting call-and-response with saxophonist Don “He plays so beautiful, don’t you agree” Myrick. — KM

David Ruffin, "Walk Away From Love" (Motown, 1975)
Ruffin struggled after leaving The Temptations, finally rallying in 1975 with "Walk Away from Love," a song written by Charles Kipps and produced by Van McCoy that topped the R&B charts and cracked the pop Top 10. Occupying the same nascent disco territory as many singles released on Philadelphia International in the mid-'70s, "Walk Away from Love" finds its insistent beat sweetened by strings and the harmonies of Faith, Hope & Charity. The smooth settings bring out the grain and texture in Ruffin's voice: his falsetto at the end of the chorus feels anguished, his voice cracking as he strives for the high note, an element that gives this polished dance tune some welcome grit. — STE

Stevie Wonder, “As” (Tamla, 1976)
There’s an embarrassment of riches throughout Wonder’s 1976 opus Songs in the Key of Life. But if you want to experience the great man at his most urgent and dramatic, push play on “As.” Wonder begins his testimony of enduring love straight by the book, as the slow, methodical buildup adds potency to his fervent commitment: “Just as hate knows love’s the cure/You can rest your mind assure/That I’ll be loving you always,” he sings. By the time jazz legend Herbie Hancock takes off on his Fender Rhodes keyboard, Wonder has turned up the intensity with a guttural declaration of faithfulness that only could come from up above. — KM

The Emotions, “Don’t Ask My Neighbors” (Columbia, 1977)
While you may be tempted to choose the Emotions’ enduring dancefloor smash “Best of My Love,” the Chicago sisters’ finest vocal moment remains the delicate R&B radio staple “Don’t Ask My Neighbors.” Produced by Earth Wind & Fire bandleader Maurice White, the poignant ballad finds Sheila Hutchinson gently assuaging a lover’s self-doubt over their relationship. But as with any heart-grabbing Emotions number, the secret sauce lies in the group’s sublime harmonies. Here, Sheila, Wanda and Jeanette deliver a seamless, dramatic blend that never lets you forget their gospel roots. — KM

THE EMOTIONS

(Michael Putland/Getty Images)

Jennifer Holliday, “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going” (Geffen, 1982)
The all-time diva flex, Holliday’s original version of “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going,” from the Broadway musical Dreamgirls, is a torch song of excruciating, almost unbearable pain and desperation. “Like the sound of thunder rolling off a mountain,” wrote Stephen Holden in the New York Times, as Holiday’s character, Effie, pleads with her no-good manager/lover to stay with her: “And YOU/and YOU/and YOU/you’re gonna love me!” she wails, one (perfectly sung) operatic convulsion after another. The song became an instant standard: Holiday earned both a Tony and a Grammy for her performance, and more than two decades later, Jennifer Hudson won an Oscar for playing Effie, and belting the showstopper, in the film version. — Craig Marks

Patti Labelle, "If You Only Knew" (Philadelphia International, 1983)
Labelle left her namesake group in the mid-1970s, not long after the runaway success of "Lady Marmalade," but she didn't have a true solo hit until "If You Only Knew," a ballad that spent four weeks at the top of the R&B charts in 1983. "If You Only Knew" marked a change of pace for the singer, with Labelle in gleaming quiet storm territory that sharply contrasted with the kinetic energy of her girl group. The restraint is the key to the song's power: Labelle spends much of the song keeping her range under wraps, which makes her runs at the end of the song so thrilling. — STE

Tina Turner, "What's Love Got To Do With It" (Capitol, 1984)
The fulcrum of Turner's 1980s comeback, "What's Love Got to Do with It" flips the script on the accepted wisdom regarding the Queen of Rock & Roll. Known for taking things nice and rough, Turner eases into the slower tempo of "What's Love Got to Do with It," the relaxed gait and gilded production bringing out a sense of heartbreak. In this sleek setting, where the synths gleam but don't overpower the song, Turner's rasp seems flinty and cutting, evidence that broken hearts have turned her into a quintessential survivor. — STE

Anita Baker, “Sweet Love” (Elektra, 1986)
It’s fitting that, early in her career, Baker drew comparisons to such distinct song stylists as Billie Holiday, Sarah Vaughan and Nancy Wilson. The Toledo, Ohio native distills a simmering intensity on this Grammy-winning single that in lesser hands would come off as sentimental smooth jazz. But Baker possesses too complex a voice for that. She takes her time, ensuring that you are wrapped up in every syllable and phrase. — KM

Whitney Houston, “Didn't We Almost Have It All" (Arista, 1987)
Early in her career, Houston specialized in bright, sunny pop and immaculate soul, both performed with finesse and flair. "Didn't We Almost Have It All" opened up a new category: grandiose ballads designed to showcase her vocal pyrotechnics, a style that would define pop for decades to come. Moving the melodrama of "The Greatest Love of All" onto a personal stage, "Didn't We Almost Have It All" is a heartbreak song delivered with the intensity of opera, as Houston's precise execution gives the polite adult-contemporary pop a real emotional thrust. — STE

PATTI LABELLE
TINA TURNER
WHITNEY HOUSTON

(Paul Natkin/Getty Images; Paul Natkin/Getty Images; Larry Busacca/Getty Images)

Michael Jackson, “Man in the Mirror” (Epic, 1987)
It starts softly enough, with Jackson announcing, “I’m gonna make a change for once in my life.” From there, he takes the Siedah Garrett- and Glen Ballard-written chart-topper to church. It was Jackson’s idea to add gospel royalty The Winans and the Andrae Crouch choir to the song to add more emotional depth. A few days later, he suggested to producer Quincy Jones that they extend the bridge, which only added anticipation for what became one of Jackson’s most celebrated vocal flourishes, as a soaring MJ implores listeners to “stand up!” against a world of despair, starving kids and homelessness. Who’s going to say no? — KM

Prince, “Adore” (Paisley Park/Warner Bros., 1987)
As usual, one-man-band Prince Rogers Nelson handled the writing and production on “Adore,” the to-the-death affirmation of love that closes his double album, Sign o’ the Times. But the real star here is Prince’s majestic falsetto, which somehow keeps up the passionate stamina for 6 minutes and 29 seconds. “You can burn up my clothes, smash up my ride…well, maybe not the ride,” he sang, playfully pledging his devotion to a paramour. — KM

Jodeci, “Lately” (Uptown/MCA, 1993)
Jodeci joined such illustrious company as Donny Hathaway, Aretha Franklin and Luther Vandross as artists who elevated a Stevie Wonder composition. That’s no small feat. But to perform the musical giant’s underrated 1980 gem “Lately” on an MTV Unplugged special, live, without a net, makes their cover all the more impressive. K-Ci and JoJo Hailey, the R&B quartet’s co-leads, strip down Wonder’s original ballad, laying bare the Charlotte, North Carolina group’s Pentecostal church background. By the time the brothers wail "'Cause this time could mean goodbye!" you’re ready to pass the collection plate. — KM

Toni Braxton “Un-Break My Heart” (LaFace, 1996)
Spending an extraordinary 11 weeks at the top of the charts, "Un-Break My Heart" is a textbook adult contemporary: It's produced by David Foster, one of the sonic architects of the format, and written by Diane Warren, a key songwriter in the genre. Braxton balked at recording the song, worried that it'd be a conventional heartbreak number. That initial reluctance may have helped the singer zero in on the song's emotional truths; her precisely controlled performance conveys great loss and yearning, transcending the conventions of the production and composition. — STE

JODECI

(Raymond Boyd/Getty Image)