AI and Likeness: Let’s Ask David Lande
Attorney David Lande is a fierce advocate for his artist clients, who are understandably ultra-protective of their names and likenesses. We asked the Ziffren Brittenham partner about navigating a constantly shifting digital environment. We don’t know why, but he decided to answer our questions.
Are your artists coming to you about unauthorized AI uses of their likeness?
Definitely. My clients either see the unauthorized uses directly or they learn about the uses from reading their direct messages online or other fan comments. Their fans often act as their eyes and ears online. Their art is so important to these fans that infringing uses really bother them
In addition, in today’s tense political climate, many of my clients are attacked online for their progressive views. Those attacks are personal, scary and often extend to family members. Those attacks often involve the unauthorized and/or manipulated use of their likeness. All of this instigates a more intense response, and deservedly so.
How do you address it? Do you feel it’s a game of whack-a-mole?
Whack-a-mole is a good way to describe it. Sometimes the labels can be helpful when recorded music is involved—many of them seem to have expedited procedures for takedowns that are helpful.
In addition, new services like Vermillio are promising additional tools for artists since they can also be effective for unauthorized images.
In today’s tense political climate, many of my clients are attacked online for their progressive views. Those attacks are personal, scary and often extend to family members. Those attacks often involve the unauthorized and/or manipulated use of their likeness. All of this instigates a more intense response, and deservedly so.
Fans like to interact with acts by creating new things with elements that may fall under the rubric of likeness—image, sound, style. How can this be navigated?
I think this is complicated, since artists have had such a difficult history of having had their work exploited.
I know that platforms like YouTube and others are hoping to build tools for artists and consumers but are hesitant to invest in building them without knowing how to aggregate the rights among a fragmented group of artists. This is unlike recorded music or publishing, which are aggregated with record companies and publishing companies, so there is no centralized source for licensing image rights.
What sorts of uses are artists OK with, and what uses might they be prepared to allow if it were monetizable on an automated basis?
Unless and until real trust is built, I think most artists would want approval of uses and would not be comfortable with anything done on an automated basis.