Black History Month

QUESTLOVE'S "SLY LIVES!": WHEN GENIUS MEETS PAIN

By Miles Marshall Lewis
February 13, 2025

Great news: SLY LIVES! (aka The Burden of Black Genius) focuses its 112-minute run time squarely on the brilliance and private turmoil of funk pioneer Sly Stone.

Director Ahmir “Questlove” Thompson rates as one of the most curious musicologists around, as evidenced by Questlove Supreme, his popular podcast. If his 2021 Summer of Soul documentary—chronicling the previously unsung Harlem Cultural Festival, featuring Sly, Nina Simone, Mahalia Jackson and others—set the tone for his directorial style, then SLY LIVES! was destined to be more ambitious than an Unsung episode.

SLY LIVES!, premiering 2/13, on Hulu, explores the fear and anxiety associated with reaching a superstar level of popularity; the purpose drugs serve in the lives of creatives who feel artistically paralyzed; the ill-at-ease feeling African Americans get from being white folks’ favorite Black person; and more.

Proving that Summer of Soul’s Best Documentary Oscar was no fluke, Questlove achieves all this without losing sight of Sly Stone.

As bandleader of the multiracial, mixed-gender rock group Sly and the Family Stone, he revolutionized psychedelic soul and funk music in the late 1960s and early '70s on albums like Stand!, There’s a Riot Goin’ On and Fresh. SLY LIVES! features crackling commentary from André 3000, D’Angelo, George Clinton, Q-Tip, Vernon Reid and others to flesh out Sly’s contributions to popular music.

Sly and the Family Stone circa 1968

Questlove divides the film into Sly’s origin story (his roots in the church, his Oakland DJ days, his early production for white rock acts like Grace Slick’s The Great Society); the meteoric rise that culminated in his historic performance at Woodstock; the sound of dissolution on There’s a Riot Goin’ On; his downward spiral into addiction; and the love of Sly’s innovations expressed by hip-hop through sampling.

One of the film’s greatest set pieces involves producer Jimmy Jam discussing the sample of “Thank You (Falettinme Be Mice Elf Agin)” that flows through Janet Jackson’s “Rhythm Nation.” Editor Joshua Pearson seamlessly runs the songs together in the background throughout Jam’s minutes-long explanation, isolating drummer Greg Errico’s breakbeat when necessary, in a subtle but masterful addition to the scene.

Questlove’s doc gets insightful mileage out of a 1982 Portrait of a Legend interview featuring Stone and appearances on The Mike Douglas Show and Late Night with David Letterman.

Still with us (hence the documentary's title) at 81, Sly reportedly wasn’t conversationally cohesive enough to appear in SLY LIVES! But another highlight of the film arrives when Reid breaks down a 1970 Dick Cavett Show appearance: When Cavett makes a condescending reference to Ernest Hemingway’s creative process, Sly replies (almost under his breath), “I’m not trying to match wits.” The exchange highlights a microaggression that Reid, as leader of the rock band Living Colour, surely recognizes from his own experience with white media.

Viewers may tune in to SLY LIVES! for the rise and fall of Stone, but most might end up staying for the insight into the burden of genius its subtitle promises. Questlove’s next documentary, on the legacy of Earth, Wind & Fire, can’t come soon enough.